The relationships of the vibratory amplitude, the vibratory torque, the derivatives of the vibratory angular displacement and the vibratory torque between components at the left end and the. The solution of a transient torsional vibra tion problem of a synchronous motor drive system is explained. Feb 08, 2001 forced torsional vibrations with damping. In order to determine the natural frequencies of torsional vibrations of the system, the holzer method has been applied. The method is strictly analogous to holzer1s idethoc31 of determining the natural frequencies of torsional vibration of shafts, and like holzer s method it is reduced to a routine tabular scheme of computation which when repeated a sufficient number of times will give the natural fre. Holzer method is employed to calculate the torsional resonant frequencies and their corresponding mode shapes. Torsional vibration in crankshafts engines mechanical. This is especially true for holzers method and the transfer matrix method. In recent years the torsional vibration behaviour of engine and powertrain components has gained in significance. The method is described and illustrated by the determination of the natural frequencies of an eightrotor freefree torsional vibration system. These vibrations can damage the machine components.
Vibrations are oscillations in mechanical dynamic systems. Pdf torsional vibration analysis of large rotor system. A tva is required to measure the angular vibration against acceptable limits. The authors purpose is to provide users with a practical design procedure that can be used to ensure that their systems will not encounter major difficulties. Exercise 10 resonance frequencies of torsional vibrations of. The deflection of disc 3 may be found by rearranging i2. An examination of the torsional vibration characteristics. This study applies the extended transfer matrix method and newtonraphson technique with complex numbers for torsional vibration analysis of damped systems. Once the two natural frequencies are established the next task is to investigate the forces that excite the vibrations in the crankshaft. Kang and chung 12 studied the transfer matrix method for the general periodic torsional vibration of rotor systems. Accordingly, this presentation concentrates on the steps that should be taken once the natural frequencies have been found. Torsional vibrations are harder to detect and hence are more. The following methods for modeling and cal culating natural frequencies and responses are described. Doc graphical user interface gui for torsional vibration.
An automatic, rootsearching, extended holzer method is described that is guaranteed to determine all the natural frequencies of a system with the exception of those values lying within prescribed tolerance bandwidth limits. Torsional vibration caused the oil pump drive shaft to fail within one hour of service. Journal of applied mechanics, transactions of asme, vol. The measurement of torsional vibration in both the field and. Holzer s method is also discussed to find the natural frequencies of branched geared systems. It could be done equally using a translational system. Exact finite element for torsional vibration of shafts under. J is the polar second holzer method 4, for the analysis of moment of area of the shaft element, i this case study.
For solution of vibration problems by the normal mode technique, the systems are classified as 1 classically damped or 2 nonclassically damped. The principle explained here is called holzers method. Introduction torsional vibration problems arose simultaneously with intensive use of mechanical engines for ship propulsion. An improved holzer procedure for torsional vibration. A rayleightype inclusion of shaft inertia in torsional. This program calculates the natural vibration frequencies of a semidefinite mechanical system with n degrees of freedom using the holzer method. Analysis of multibranch torsional vibration for design optimization.
In order to in this paper, the need for matlab prepare engineers to completely solve as a programming tool to design and these problems numerically, the build a graphical user interface gui for the analysis of torsional vibration fact that the shaft response is primarily in rotor systems using holzer in the lower order modes of vibration. When a shaft is transmitting torque it is subjected to twisting of torsional deflection. Torsional vibrations christian brothers university. In contrast to lateral vibration problems, torsional failures are especially heinous since the first symptom of a problem is often a broken shaft, gear tooth, or coupling. A fortran code is developed for the undamped free vibration analysis of the. The propulsion system is modeled as a flexible shaft with multiple inertias as lumped masses and shaft sections with torsional stiffness. Vibration of two and multidegree of freedom systems nptel. Huang analyzed the engine excitation on a transmission with a damper for the converter operation. Holzer s method, for obtaining the machines natural frequencies. A simple algorithm for torsional vibration analysis. Evaluation of methods for analysis of multidegreeoffreedom.
These notes develop the method using a torsional system. A segment of this torsional vibration system is shown in figure 3. Agn 235 generating set assembly torsional vibration analysis. The objective of the work is to show the usefulness and power of matlab gui in investigating and analyzing the effects of torsional vibration on rotor systems. And thence the results obtained using finite element method are compared with those. The method of analysis of torsional vibrations most often used today was presented by h.
Rayleighs, dunkerleys, stodolas and holzer s methods. Torsional vibrations with multiple modes freestudy. Torsional vibrations occur due torelative oscillatory motions superposed on the mean rotation. Analysis of torsional vibration characteristics for multirotor and gear. Several case histories are detailed and references to other torsional analysis material is provided. Correlation to a mathematical model and solutions to torsional problems are presented. The hol zer method calculates natural frequencies and mode shapes of torsional systems by assuming a frequency and starting with a unit amplitude displacement at one end of the system and progressively. The matrix methods, that are more suitable for computer based. Analysis of torsional vibration characteristics for multirotor and gearbranched systems using finite element method. The torsional vibration analysis may be carried out by both numerical and analytical methods such as the transfer matrix method, the finite element method and holzer method. Experimental determination of mass moment of inertia j. The natural frequency and torsional vibration amplitude is determined by holzer tabulation method and also by using engine simulation software.
An algorithm for holzer method is designed and programmed using matlab software. Torsional vibration response of rotating machinery must. Computeraided design software for torsional analysis citeseerx. Torsional natural frequencies are a function of the torsional mass inertia and the torsional stiffness between the masses. A driveline could be an engine and alternator combination in a generating set. Torsional analysis an overview sciencedirect topics. Torsional vibration case histories in vibration analysis. Natural frequency of a rifle barrel with freefree boundary conditions. Mode shapes and natural frequency of multi rotor system. This iterative method is used to estimate the torsional natural frequencies and their corresponding modal shapes supposing a frequency and unitary amplitude in one end of the system and progressively calculating torque and angular displacement until reaching another end 4. Practical design against torsional vibration by mark a. In this study, the numerical free vibration analysis of multi shaftdisc systems is studied. This way system modifications can be made with greater certainty of success. Holzer s method is usually presented as a means for determining natural fre quencies and mode shapes for closecoupled systems.
Mass moment of inertia of the disk is large compared with the mass moment of inertia of the shaft. Crankshaft by using holzer method and finite element method shantanu jayant chaudhari1, krunal chandrashekhar chaudhari2, 1,2department of automobile engineering,north maharashtra university, jalgaon abstract. The natural frequencies and mode shapes are generally calculated by the holzer method or by eigenvalueeigenvector procedures 40. A study on fea of torsional vibration in geared shafts. An examination of the torsional vibration characteristics of. The deflection of disc 2 may be found by rearranging i1. The torsional vibration analysis of marine power transmission is a challenging subject and it.
While this is true, the method is applicable also to the forced response of both undampled and damped systems. Reference 10 investigated the free vibrations analysis of a rotating shaft with nonlinearities in curvature and inertia. An improved holzer procedure for torsional vibration analysis. Fault detection of inline reciprocating diesel engine. Torsional vibration is gaining the attention of the industrial community due to its high influence in the integrity of the machine components1. Torsional vibration calculation issues with propulsion systems dr. One of the foremost concerns facing turbomachinery users today is that of torsional vibration. The holzer method is used to calculate natural frequency mostly in torsional vibration systems, which is a tabular method for the analysis of. It is obvious that the torque due to pressure and inertia varies dramatically over the 720degree cycle for each cylinder, with about a 20% variation. Analysis of torsional vibration characteristics for multi.
Torsional vibration is a subject that should be of concern to all turbomachinery users. Therefore, free or forced torsional vibration analysis of rotating shafts is of utmost importance in the dynamic design stage. Torsional analysis problems can become extremely complicated and theoretical modeling often must be tempered with actual field measurements. Pdf torsional vibration is a frequent perturb for heavy rotating and high speed machinery. Torsional vibrations with multiple modes multiple inertia system figure 1 if we have several discs on a shaft as shown, there are several possible nodes and natural frequencies. Using the holzer procedure given in it is clear from this figure that the first reference 5, the t. Transverse vibration of a string, longitudinal vibration of a bar, torsional vibration of a shaft. Evaluation of methods for analysis of multidegreeof. Recall that rotational simple harmonic motion is described by. This paper discusses several aspects of measuring and analysing torsional vibration and related. Torsional response at the compressor ode was excessive at the 6th order of run speed. Torsional vibration measurement and analysis of improved. Exact forced torsional vibration solution of a shaft with.
The word users, utilized throughout this work, refers to all engineers, including designers, analysts. Mode shapes and natural frequency of multi rotor system with. Holzer s method, for obtaining the machines natural frequencies and mode shapes. The pump was subsequently replaced but again failed within one hour of service. Using holzers method determine the natural frequencies for to. Graphical user interface gui for torsional vibration. Laskin, orcutt and shipley 9,10, in 1968, used the holzer torsional vibration models of simple and planetary gearing system to compute gear tooth dynamic forces. The calculated is the polar second moment of inertia torsional natural frequencies are shown of. To prevent fatigue or wear damage to the engine, alternator or the attached drivetrain. Abstract in this study, a new approach for the torsional vibration analysis of rotor systems using holzer and matlab techniques, by developing a graphical user interface gui, has been introduced. Torsional vibration is a type of severe twisting motion due to improperly designed.
Holzer s method of solution proposes that we assume any value of. Torsional vibration i simple systems with one or two rotor masses rt 28 ii multidof systemstransfer matrix method rt14 29 iii geared system rt15 30 iv branched system rt16 31 ix. After the torsional natural frequencies are calculated, forced vibration. Torsional vibration is often a concern in power transmission systems using rotating shafts or couplings where it can cause failures if not controlled. Holzer method for calculating torsional and linear multimass systems. Holzer method, torsional vibration, natural frequencies, mode shapes, critical speeds, marine diesel engine shafting system.
In this paper, by using the holzer method and the finite element method the natural frequencies of torsional vibration. Pdf torsional natural frequencies by holzer method researchgate. Torsional stresses and vibration have great influence. Torsional vibration analysis of large rotor system using finiteelement and matlab procedures. Computer method for forced torsional vibration of propulsive shafting system of marine engine with or without. But the stories about ship shafts snapping became regularly printed on the newspapers pages since 1870. Holzers method, for obtaining the machines natural frequencies and mode. Exact finite element for torsional vibration of shafts. The difficulty of detecting incipient failures in the field makes the performance of a thorough torsional vibration analysis an essential component of the turbomachinery design process. Using holzers method determine the natural frequencies of the springmass. Analysis of torsional vibration systems by the extended.
859 1214 287 1236 968 327 88 858 866 1018 318 688 466 1216 1546 1580 214 1391 274 868 991 383 1499 219 327 556 802 1118 1013 1009